School Property Tax Debate Reaches PA: Argall's Tax Shift Plan Criticized - Essay Sample

Paper Type:  Essay
Pages:  7
Wordcount:  1835 Words
Date:  2023-07-19


The school property tax bills reached in mailboxes all over Pennsylvania around July, and a more extensive debate on the elimination of the tax is predicted to commence. The attempts to repeal the tax have been in existence for decades. Argall has initiated some of the legislation that is likely to compensate for the monetary loss in various increased taxes. Some of the groups, such as Feeding Pennsylvania that represents over eight food banks tended to criticize tax shift legislation (Tynan, 2002). A bipartisan group of state senators seems to have initiated a bill to eliminate school property taxes in Pennsylvania. For instance, Senate Bill 76 would expound an individual income tax to restore school property taxes and providing the ability to enhance additional revenues via earned income or personal income tax.

Trust banner

Is your time best spent reading someone else’s essay? Get a 100% original essay FROM A CERTIFIED WRITER!

However, the levying of the increased sales tax may enhance additional hardships on the low-income people, and the improved personal income tax tends to sanction individuals who work hard. Moreover, the inadequately educated population tends to be costly to the community and also wasting public money regardless of the method to attain those dollars. Some perceive the system to be inequitable and punitive for fixed-income seniors and even lower-income is evident that Pennsylvania has over 500 school districts that comprise of $ 25 billion in debt, with only either school free (Sweet & Symons, 1989).

However, if the remaining taxes are not eliminated, then the remaining schools are likely to feel the negative impact. For instance, business to business will not have to be taxed as both individual and business may have to retain the same law firm, but only the individual's bill to be taxed. Witt (2009) Pennsylvania lawmakers resuscitate the existing bill to eliminate school property taxes, and thus the bill would enhance the revenue by maximizing the personal income tax from 3 to 4%.

Pennsylvania Lawmakers Revive Bill to Eliminate School Property Taxes

It is believed that the presence of the bill in the Pennsylvania sante may render school property tax irrelevant, with the Senate Majority Committee meeting to debate on Senate Bill 76 meant to eliminate the taxes. It is estimated that property taxes are not fair ever since the 1830s, which were put in place when the children used to learn from a single room and the tutors paid partially. Many people believe that if you do not pay the same tax, you may not be able to meet mortgage requirements. The state of Pennsylvania has actually attempted to repeal the unfair tax that facilitated some level of hardship for most constituents. Some individuals believe that legislative action is needed to prevent property taxpayers from being perceived as a black check. Others feel that the bill, how an increase in the sales tax may enhance lower lower-wage earners, and the repercussions of entirely eliminating the school property tax. The bill is currently on the Senate Finance Committee.

Pennsylvania Property Tax Cut Proposals Unveiled

Several plans were put together by different groups that represented parties and chambers of the General Assembly, such as the Wolf management, headed by Argall, who has been attempting to enhance property tax elimination for many years. Peters, (2006) the strategy to cut Pennsylvania property taxes by over $ 8 billion using sales taxes or personal taxes had been applied. The debates had initiated the following proposals:

A cut back of $8.6 billion in school property taxes. The primary components which enhanced the revenue are optimization on the state's personal tax to 4.06%. A personal increase in tax would be introduced to reduce millage rates. Over 30% of average local school tax minimization for all properties

A $6.4 billion minimization in school property taxes. The sources of finance are still being estimated.

Initiating a rebate project which would provide a rebate to several owners of real estate properties

A project that would rebate over $ 5000 to homestead property owners.

An introduction of $ 8.5 billion eliminations of all the school property taxes for the homestead property owners; thus, the personal income tax would be increased.

Many of the legislators argue that flat-out elimination of the existing school property tax is not practically effective. Practically the ultimate property tax reform bill, which resulted in a vote in Harrisburg, took place in 2015. Some of the debaters however, felt that the credibility of the plans engaging rebates encountered various challenges because they did not determine what the other taxes would have raised in the long run.

Pennsylvania School Property Tax Options Ready for Lawmakers

The ultimate product is a brief list of alternatives on how to shift the load of financing a huge school district functioning costs from prom property taxes. The legislators terminated the process showing the stake are significant in figuring out how it could be possible to deal with the pressing issues at hand.

The tax is approximated to, too, have raised 15 billion dollars for the state's school districts. Currently, the average property tax bill for various homesteads was estimated to be over $ 2,300 (Muracca, 2011). However, the bills tend to differ, relying on the available rates and the existing property assessments. It is reported that many of the senior citizens have had challenging times trying to pay the tax; with many legislators citing that most of the elders have had to lose their homes due to the existing property tax. On the other hand, any interference with the financing of the school must be very sensitive to the existing huge imbalance between educational provisions in the districts and with the many underprivileged families.

Additionally, a multi-district lawsuit has suggested that the state's school financing systems tend to build massive funding differences and critically discriminate against the less privileged in the society. For instance, currently Republican Sen. Mario addressed the issue on property taxes, he said that "one 88-year-old resident paid less than $500 in property tax in 1984 and now pays $5,000 on the same property (Muracca, 2011)." Trying to express the level of desperation that some of the seniors had to undergo. It is currently argued that senior citizens need to be the first to gain from the proposed property tax reduction plan. Various debates have been on the combination of an optimization in the state personal income tax and sales taxes to offset property tax relief. Moreover, district by district cost tends to approximate any financial impacts that have been initiated.

Reasons PA's School Property Taxes Are Challenging

Other taxes would have to rise

Several legislators have tried to actively propose for the elimination of school district property taxes, normally introduced as 76 bills. For instance, Argall initiated the last part of the Senate bill 76. It stated that the state would:

Maximize the personal income tax rate to 4.9%

Enhance the sales of the state tax rate to 7%

Expound on what is covered by the sales tax of the state

A Challenge to Pennsylvania

The current Pennsylvania's education system placed a significant weight on the taxpayers locally compared to other states. For instance, the steps offer over 37% of the financial support to the public K-12 schools annually. Therefore, setting a status quo that is relatively challenging to alter.

Any alteration risks a potential reprisal.

The Pennsylvania legislators had approved a plan to alter the local tax system. For instance, the homeowners were to expect property tax minimization in exchange for enabling local administration to increase income taxes. However, the citizens were never persuaded effectively and were not fully convinced. It is estimated that an average individual may have difficulty regarding the gain of the plan to their own personal situations. However, during the current Pennsylvania Press Club luncheon, they referenced the long history of the property tax discussion in Pennsylvania.

There is a wide range of opponents.

The idea on the Pennsylvania's School Property Tax Bill tends not to break down effectively. Teacher unions, corporate groups, food banks, and other agencies have categorically criticized school property tax elimination based on varied reasons. For instance, The Pennsylvania Chamber of Business and Industry suggests that eliminating property taxes is likely to move the load and not addressing the existing unfinanced mandate and cost drivers. Additionally, the chamber also suggested that the finance from property taxes is relatively more reliable compared to income and sales taxes (Jones, 1993). On the other hand, The Pennsylvania School Boards Association feels that the proposed elimination of school taxes may benefit many businesses, but harm specific persons, thus resulting in underfinancing of schools. Most of those opposing the idea like to argue that, under the elimination plans; the property taxes are likely to be stagnant unless a district's local debt is settled.

Nonetheless, the new amendment of 2017 has enabled legislators to eliminate property taxes for an individuals' primary residence yet maintaining them for industrial and any other property. Even though many may prefer to eliminate school property taxes for all, homeowners have their options written. They may possibly be included as an amendment into the existing Senate Bill 1976, failing to move ahead (Sweet & Symons, 1989). Nonetheless, the elimination of property taxes to homeowners would still cost quite a huge sum of money. The current initiatives, to emphasize on the major residences to be positive and are in the appropriate direction.

A bill in the Pennsylvania Senate would make school property taxes would make up the revenue by enhancing the personal income tax to 4.95%. Nonetheless, the legislative effort is needed to maintain property taxpayers for being perceived as a blank check. An increase in the sales tax is likely to impact lower-wage earners and thus resulting in eliminating the school property tax.

PA’s Current School Property Tax and if It Is Fair

The local government in the United States has implemented various tax and expenditure limitations. The most common tax procedure that the US government used in Pennsylvania is the property tax limit. Depending on the level of the tax value that Pennsylvania could have on the relief chosen, then the revenue could be compromised in the case where the public service could not comprise the situation where the revenue substitution could not meet the expenditure by the government (Budzilek, 2009). It is important to note that the taxation process is the economy that has a symbiotic relationship with the policies which are set by the government.

It is common knowledge that all the government and their services depend on the revenue that is collected from the possible fees and the taxes. The purpose of the government and all the possible activities that the government is likely to achieve are set in the constitution. The Senate of Pennsylvania, in its resolution of the year 2010, made a directive which the legislative budget and the finance committee were to implement on the current tax collection system. The resolution which was made by the committee was also to consider any costs and the available benefits which could be generated from the collection of the current tax, which was made. In fact, it is essential to note that the Pennsylvanian is being consolidated at the municipal level. It is the primary responsibility of the elected municipal collectors to collect all the county, civil, and school property taxes.

The Pennsy...

Cite this page

School Property Tax Debate Reaches PA: Argall's Tax Shift Plan Criticized - Essay Sample. (2023, Jul 19). Retrieved from

Free essays can be submitted by anyone,

so we do not vouch for their quality

Want a quality guarantee?
Order from one of our vetted writers instead

If you are the original author of this essay and no longer wish to have it published on the ProEssays website, please click below to request its removal:

didn't find image

Liked this essay sample but need an original one?

Hire a professional with VAST experience and 25% off!

24/7 online support

NO plagiarism