U.S. Gov't Forced Native Americans to Settle in Unfavorable Lands - Essay Sample

Introduction

At the end of the Civil War, the Native Americans were more concentrated in the North American continent. A larger number of the tribes were pushed to settle in the west of river Mississippi where Americans also were interested in settling (Fonner, 2004). The tribes were being forced by the federal government to sign treaties and settle in the reservations that is, each tribe was designated its land. In most cases, the tribes were allocated the worst parts of a region which was inadequate to fulfil the population's needs

Is your time best spent reading someone else’s essay? Get a 100% original essay FROM A CERTIFIED WRITER!

Save 25%

The whites settled in the reservations which were desirable, for example, those with golds and suitable farmlands. They would later raise complaints to the federal government that they are being attacked in the Indian land. Such selfish motives imply that military conquests were inevitable (Foner, 2004). The reason is that the U.s army had to intervene for their citizens and they would come and chase out the tribes who were rightfully supposed to settle there. Tribes such as Apache led raids that were murderous against those who settled in their land

The Comanche Society in the Mid-Nineteenth Century

In the 19th century, this society practised a traditional Indian culture that was decentralized. They had undergone a lot of changes as a result of the Europeans movement into America. For instance, they had acquired horses from the Spanish people, thus enabling them to expand their territory of hunting. There existed no political groups that would be referred to as tribes (Gelo & Hämäläinen, 2009). There existed informal organizations where the members of the society were distributed in autonomous bands which were loosely organized. There were outstanding fighters known as the war chiefs who had long achievement records against their enemies.

There was freedom for any individual to plan for a war party as long as he could influence others to follow him. Still, he only acquired leadership roles when individuals volunteered to follow him, and during that particular raid, they obtained wealth by raiding from advancing Euro-Americans and other Indian communities (Gelo & Hämäläinen, 2009). There were also heads of the band known as "peace chiefs", but they had no formal authority either. They were wise men well respected by the members of the band who made decisions of day to day routine of operating activities, for example, where and when the camp will be relocated.

There existed an individual's property rights that were set in ownership of private properties such as horses, construction materials, weapons, tools for hunting and gathering and different body ornaments used in religious activities. In this community, they believed that an individual is supreme in all things (Gelo & Hämäläinen, 2009). The ostracism threat was one used to encourage respect of rules concerning any individual that is any man who faced a legal wrong was to take action against the wrongdoer or else encounter social disgrace as a coward.

The Response of the Comanche Society to Mainstream American Encroachment on Their Homeland

The Comanche community dominated the most significant area of West, North and Central Texas. Out of the thirteen Comanche's bands, five of them played prominent roles in the history of Texas. Following the buffalo, the community-led a nomadic lifestyle. They were in control of buffalo products, captives, trade produce and horses during the time of their domain. By warring with the Apaches and the Spanish, the Comanche made their presence known in Texas (Jones, 2017). The Spanish signed a peace treaty with them in fear of losing Texas to the Comanche. After the Spanish failing to observe their promises in trade products and gifts, the Comanche resumed their raiding against them. They traded the stolen horses to the Americans who had newly arrived.

Americans interest was settling in Texas plains after the Texas revolution. The Comanche violently resisted their encroachment with raids on the frontier that were deadly and destructive. During the reign of President Mirabeau B. Lamar, the raiding and retaliation cycle climaxed. They succeeded to drive away from the Comanche to the other side of Red River; however, it was at a terrible cost to both parties. Later after Texas became a state, a few Comanche members were defeated by buffalo depletion, disease and warfare, thus moving to an Indian territory for reservation (Jones, 2017).The rest were left active and succeeded in stopping the spread of Americans' encroachment in the west of Texas hill country.

Factors That Contributed to the Defeat of the Comanche Society by the Military

There was a significant attack launching against buffalo hunters at Adobe walls. The raid pulled down a retaliatory campaign of the U.S army which destroyed the Comanche power wholly by the destruction of their horses. The Comanche's camp and all its supplies and about 1400 horses that were abandoned were burnt down. An order was given by Mackenzie, who was the leader of the military after acquiring the best parts of the mounts to send all horsemen unrivalled into despair (Jones, 2017). Because all essential things, food supplies and the essential horses were gone there is no way the Comanche could go hunting and get back their essential supplements. The society was left with no option but to surrender and start a painful change process to reservation life and the raiders no longer impeded the expansion of the American frontier towards the west.

References

Foner, E. (2004). Give me liberty! (5th ed.). W. W. Norton & Company.

Gelo, D., & Hämäläinen, P. (2009). The Comanche Empire. The Journal Of American History, 96(1), 214. https://doi.org/10.2307/27694782

Jones, K. (2017). The story of Comanche: horsepower, heroism and the conquest of the American West. War & Society, 36(3), 156-181. https://doi.org/10.1080/07292473.2017.1356588