Paper Example on National Immigration Policy: Who Should Regulate?

The power to regulate immigration in the country has been in the hand of the national government for over 100 years. However, in recent years there has been a gradual transfer of enforcement authority to the state’s government. The mandate to control the immigration policy should be left with the national government (Abrams, 2019). This is because there have been several cases of mistreatment and racial profiling and the state level. Moreover, the national government is in a better position to implement immigration policy has it has vast resources than the local government. Moreover, should each state enact its own immigration laws would violate the doctrine that states are precluded from regulating filed that Congress has determined must be regulated by its exclusive governance.

Is your time best spent reading someone else’s essay? Get a 100% original essay FROM A CERTIFIED WRITER!

Save 25%

The national governments delegate some functions to the state’s governments. However, there are certain areas where the national government might underperform, and the state governments should make sure where such instances are observed they step in and enforce congressional law. This because the issues and problems that come immigration will affect them more than the national government (Abrams, 2019). Primarily, the state governments do not step in and implement the congressional they will be flooded with illegal immigrants, overwhelmed social service systems, driven down wages, and increased crime rate.

The Immigration policy at the national level is indeed unlikely to receive any significant change. The immigration policy has been built upon the reunification of families, protecting refugees, promoting diversity, and admitting people with skills that are important to improve the economy. Therefore, the immigration policy is unlikely to receive any change at the national level.

The guest worker program has been debated over the past few years, with people having divergent views regarding the issue. The supporters of the guest worker program argue that such an expanded program will benefit both the American workers and guest workers. Primarily, the United States chamber of commerce argues that the country is experiencing a shortage of workers in hotels, restaurants, hospitals, a construction (Abrams, 2019). Consequently, the guest worker program would curb unauthorized immigration by giving immigrant legal means to work and stay in the country. Moreover, the program allows United States industries to fill nonprofessional and skilled employees, which they cannot find qualified U.S workers for. The disadvantages of the program will encourage illegal immigration, lead to large-scale permanent settlement of immigrants, and exploitation of both undocumented and American workers. Donald Trump and the republican party are likely to reject this proposal.

Faultlines Issue: Civil Liberties: Should There Be A Religious Exemption to Nondiscrimination Laws?

The argument does not represent the true nature of the community. Each individual has the right to believe in the religion he or she likes. No individual should be denied employment or service because of their beliefs or personal practice. Therefore, there should be no such exemptions in the law.

The government can mandate that all individuals be served equally, and such practices should be abolished (Doering, 2018). The governments should ensure that services are offered to people equally and laws as enacted to protect vulnerable people such as African-America and same-sex marriages.

Each individual should be allowed to practice the religion, and he or she deems right. The government needs to enact laws such groups of people are protected. Primarily there are human rights that protect people from discrimination (Doering, 2018). The government should make sure human rights are implemented as they will protect all people from discrimination.

References

Doering, M. D. (2018). A Liberal Analysis of Religious Exemptions to Public Accommodation Laws. https://dc.uwm.edu/etd/1784

Abrams, J. R. (2019). Why the legal strategy of exploiting immigrant families should worry us all. Harv. L. & Pol'y Rev., 14, 77.