How can psychological violence be accurately and validly defined as a Violence against Women (VAW) when most of its effects are mental and cannot be physically quantified? Where does normative psychological aggression (non-harmful) become psychological violence (harmful)? How can any violence against women qualify as a psychological violence when psychologists and researchers on Violence against Women such as Mauiro admit that schema useful for classification and intervention are as of the moment undetermined? Do younger women attract a higher prevalence of VAW because they have less control and power over their decisions and have fewer options? Does age disparity play a big role in cases of VAW especially for younger women and how? How can depression, the most significant variable studied concerning VAW, be a conclusive determinant when there is no clear link between the two? (Campbell et al, 2005) Why dont studies focus solely on either understanding VAW or understanding the scientific explanations behind VAW instead of having a double-objective?
To me the report is frustrating. It is maddening the way the article uses assumptions even in supportive literature. There are a lot of holes and inconsistencies all through it. It has been hurriedly put together, the authors of the report themselves admit to inadequacy of the literature on mental health effects of VAW (Jordan et al, 2010). There is few concrete points to take from the article, the main point being more research has to be done on the field of violence against women. What could be hampering research on VAW over the last thirty years could be having two primary opposing reasons for conducting the research; scientific understanding and ending the violence. I cannot understand why researches and studies cannot be more objective-oriented. This could explain why it has been disappointing. Most of the researches and studies have so far been theoretical and not supported by empirical models and research techniques. It is hard for somebody to read through a report which you know poses more questions than answers. It is mentally challenging processing information which at first appears to be scientifically sound until you discover there are assumptions behind some claims.
It is apparent that VAW has mental effects on victimized women. The main documented mental health effect of VAW on victimized women is Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) and depression. All in all the research on the outcome of VAW is inconclusive because the literature covering the same is unreliable. Clearly, much has to be done to stop occurrences of VAW and scientific reforms have to be pushed if any headway is to be made in ending VAW.
Campbell JC, Sullivan CM, Davidson WS. 1995. Depression in women who use domestic violence shelters: A longitudinal analysis. Psychol. Women Q. 19:237255.
Jordan, C. E., Campbell, R., & Follingstad, D. (2010). Violence and women's mental health: the impact of physical, sexual, and psychological aggression. Annual review of clinical psychology, 6, 607-628.
If you are the original author of this essay and no longer wish to have it published on the ProEssays website, please click below to request its removal:
- Willie and Billie in Death of the Salesman: The Problem of Trust and Psychological Breakdown
- A Place Where I Belong: Germany. Personality Essay Example
- Summary of the Article: Impact of Gratitude of Resource Development and Emotional Well-being
- Effects of Illegal Immigrants in California State. Sociology Paper Sample
- Is There a Moral Obligation to Obey the Law? Article Review Example
- Essay Example on Racial Discrimination and Other Sociological Issues in America
- Essay on BTK Killer: The Public and Media Trial
- Coastal Community Studies: Rockaway and Long Beach, New York after Hurricane Sandy
- Articles Review on Prison Health Care
- Evolution in the Court's Jurisprudence in Canada: Law Essay Sample
- Should Private Security Personnel Have a Stronger Background in Business or Criminal Justice?
- Right to a Family and Private Life
- Hispanic Children and Youth Including
- Essay Sample: Population on Earth, Carrying Capacity, Birth Rate, Death Rate
- Violence Against Women and Girls - Sociology Essay Example