The Differences Between the Book "Iliad" and the Film "Troy" Essay Example

Introduction

The differences between the book "Iliad" and the film "Troy" is evident throughout the events and various plots in the two concepts. The Book Troy is an English poem regarding the history of the Trojan War. It is a great tool for elaborating the start of Iliad right after Troy had fallen. The movie traces its original story from the conflict Trojan-Greeks which lead to the fall of Troy and the death Achilles. The two items are based on Trojan conflict. This article compares the movie of Troy and the Book troy in terms of plot and the events.

Is your time best spent reading someone else’s essay? Get a 100% original essay FROM A CERTIFIED WRITER!

Save 25%

Plot Differences

The book and the film show distinguishing features regarding the plot of the stories, focus, and the entire coverage. The movie tries to explain the reason s as to why Trojan-Greeks developed whereas the book begins from its story from the onset Trojan war from the ninth year and the fight between Agamemnon and Achilles as well as its strength (Solomon, 2015). The book focusses the transformation in the character of Achilles at the end. The book is set to how the resolution of the anger of the Achilles and the movie entails the solution itself. It pictures the differences and the solutions to the conflict between Greeks and the Trojans. Despite the fact that the movie's focus is on the settlement of the conflict, Achilles remains a hero in the story. The war relied on him and all participants took him a leader. The movie is more comprehensive and compressed and in order to fit the whole story into place some of the features of different characters were altered. For instance, Briseis is used to depict the conflict between Agamemnon and Achilles. She forgets about the objective of the war towers the end of the story, also Briseis gives Myrmidons freedom to flee. The incident of Briseis causes the draws Achilles into greater anger however this event is used differently in the book and the film. The book uses this incident to show weakness. the film involves emotions, Achilles abandons the rest in the during the war. The movie retains the wrath of Achilles towards Agamemnon and the cause of it and as a result of an alteration of features of a character, there are some of the contradiction involved which do not occur in the book (Berk Albachten, 2016). The existence of Aeneas (the survivor who fueled endurance of Troy) is not integrated into the movie, he remains a regular villager, however, in the book; he is given a character of glory, he becomes a great soldier enough to act as a protector of Trojans.

Audience and Cultural Perceptions

The change of audience is also one of the differences, the contemporary audience in the film differs in cultural perceptions with those in the book. In addition, the responsibility of the gods is differently explored in the two perspectives. The movie limits the side mythology to omens whereas in the mythology controlled almost the entire uprising of the mortal's clash. The film makes some twist to sharpen the plot of the story Achilles asks "what is the purpose of having gods in a battle", this question showed how the film underrated the role of gods. In terms of the theme, the book gives a clear relationship between the mythological differences regarding the changes involved during war progress. The movie is set to reflect a modernized society where magic does not have a role to play (Rabel, 2018). During the battlefield, God's appearance and their involvement are mentioned in the book. Gods are highly respected, Briseis mentions, "every god deserves respect and should be feared". The profiles of the characters are shortening in the movie making it setting a limited course in terms of budget production.

References

Berk Albachten, O. (2016). The myth of Troy as a lieu de memoire: Turkish cultural memory and translations of the Iliad in the 1950s. Classical Receptions Journal, 9(2), 287-306.

Rabel, R. J. (2018). THE STRUCTURE OF THE ILIAD. The Classical Review, 68(1), 16.

Solomon, J. (2015). Homer's Iliad in Popular Culture: The Roads to Troy. In Return to Troy (pp. 248-279). BRILL.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ) for Essay:

What are the main differences in the plot between the book "Iliad" and the film "Troy"?

Film "Troy" delves deeper into the development of Trojan-Greek conflict while book "Iliad" begins its story during year 9 of the Trojan War and centers around Agamemnon and Achilles' fight - while film focuses more on conflict settlement while book explores changes to Achilles' personality.

How do the book and the film differ in terms of character portrayals?

The film simplifies and alters certain character features to fit its narrative. For instance, Briseis plays an active role in depicting Agamemnon-Achilles tension while her role emphasized Achilles' weakness in the book. Furthermore, Aeneas does not feature prominently as an important survivor of Troy as seen in the book where he becomes an excellent warrior protecting Trojans.

How do the book and the film differ in their treatment of gods and mythology?

The film downplays gods as mere omens, while in the book their influence over mortal conflict was prominently explored through mythology. Gods were respected more highly during battle scenes while their presence is questionable in battle scenes in film form; while in book format gods would make regular appearances at battle sites to show their significance and provide guidance during combat scenarios.