Quantitative Research Critique Paper Example

Introduction

Critiquing is a skill used in Nursing and other disciplines to closely look at a particular study in details. The skill tries to evaluate the work of that particular discipline, and then from the approaches used in analyzing the research being examined, the expert analyzing the work is able to conclude that the analysis is of merit or demerit to the users. The critiquing quantitative skills, try to analyze the merit that a research employed in gathering their numerical data. The data analyzed can be in form of weights or mass, or length, volume, etc. On the other hand, the qualitative sample described by the writer is also looked into to affirm their strengths and weakness. (Ryan, Coughlan & Cronin 2007)

Is your time best spent reading someone else’s essay? Get a 100% original essay FROM A CERTIFIED WRITER!

Save 25%

The case study of this research uses the different leading statement to find out the following statement of the problem from the articles of Nursing; was the critical points addressed by the two articles? Were their new ideas in the two articles, were their elaborate recommendations, was their room given in the two articles for the two types of research.

QUANTITATIVE RESEARCH CRITIQUE

Research Problem and Purpose

The purpose of the BMC Geriatrics is to realize the psychosocial needs of the people with mental problems. It, therefore, offers a qualitative approach to the problem in relation to different believes and activities in a healthcare provider. On the other hand, the Journal of Nursing UFPE online is written to give the prevention measures of urinary infections. It uses the qualitative approach as an indicator of nursing aid to the aging group.

Hypotheses and Research Questions

In the article of prevention of urinary infection; the following information can be obtained from them, first, the journal clearly states it objectively which is basically the ways in which the article can be helpful to people with the urinary infection. On the other hand, the article of the BMC Geriatrics tries to find out away in which the persons with the mental problem can regain his or her normal social live hood. Secondly, the article of prevention measure of urinary infection give the give the find of 256 patients that were examined in a hospital under the nurse's care and the result tabulated on page 3154. On the other hand the BMC on stated their findings and elaborated them, for example, the finding of the physical need oriented logics, the renouncement logics among other elaborated. The articles are therefore useful for their targeted group it is only that the one giving preventive measure is very precise to the points while the one BMC is very elaborate.

Literature Review

The Journal of Nursing gives a brief explanation on the abstract cover page concerning the prevention measure of urinary infections. The BMC Geriatrics gives a brief explanation of the ways in which other researchers have attempted to re-stabilize the social live hood of dementia persons. The explanation is on the abstract page.

Theoretical or Conceptual Framework

In the journal of nursing, the framework is one year that is from 2015 to 2016, whereas that of BMC used a descriptive design from other published works.

Protection of Human Research Participants

In the BMC geriatrics, the research sampled 24 health cares and it was through interviews. For the case of Nursing Journals, 129 randomly selected patients were examined.

Protection of Human Research Participants

Both methods of data collection were done by trained personnel's so that the participants care is upheld.

Research Design

In the Journal of Nursing the research was a model of the previous research studies, while in the BMC, the research was designed from other articles and books with related ideas.

Instruments and Strategies for Measurement

In the Journal of Nursing, the researchers used the computers to analyze the data in excel sheet format. On the other hand, the recorders were to store information that was later transcribed. The rationale of the research, relevancy of the research, collection of data, instruments used purpose of the research and other relevant disciplines to the research. (Stockhausen &Conrick 2002)

9. Data Collection

In the case of the Journal of Nursing group of nurses moved from one federal district hospital to the other sampling the patients' urine. On the other hand, the data collection was done through a semi-focused group that did interviews.

10. Data Analysis

The data analysis was as follows, BMC used systematic text condensing and Nursing journals used excel spreadsheet to analyze the findings.

11. Interpretation of Results

The data analyses of the Journal warrant reliability since they were given in tabular form. While that of mainly in text form and therefore lacks authenticity.

12. Discussion of Findings

The data were analyzed in both cases and the objectives of the two types of research were met. The Journal of Nursing gave their findings and the prevention measures outline similarly the BMC journal gave the approaches to redeeming mental retardations.

13. Limitations

Both types of research are vague on the limitations of the researchers these imply that for further understanding of the limitations one must excavate deeply into the work.

14. Implications

The implications of the research are not conspicuous. This means that the hypotheses are not affirmed in all of them.

15. Recommendations

In the Journal of Nursing, the recommendations are not clearly drowned. This is one of the major setbacks of this research while for the case of BMC the recommendations for further research are stipulated which is a plus on the journal.

16. Research Utilization in Your Practice

The two types of research are very useful for my nursing training since they build on the general studies involving nursing. Using the defended dissertation of Riviera of the qualitative analysis method it's clear that it is science. (Riviera D 2017). And the analysis is very useful for any individual aspiring to be a nurse.

References

Riviera, D. (2011). Successful Writing and defending the dissertation proposal: A Review of Designing Qualitative Research. Qualitative Report

Ryan, F, Coughlan, M & Cronin, P 2007, Step-by-step guide to critiquing research. Part 2: qualitative research, British Journal of Nursing

Stockhausen L &Conrick, M 2002, Making sense of Research: a guide for critiquing paper, contemporary Nurse