Essay Sample on Manliness & Race: A Historical Perspective on Civilization

Introduction

Gail Bederman's Manliness and Civilization, which was published in 1995, explains how manliness is associated with race and civilization. She states out that historians describe manhood as a regular aspect of human nature, although it can be expressed in different forms and at various times of life. Bederman explains that the concept of what it means to be a man is ever-changing as a result of the ideology which occurs at a time as well as real actions of the men as exemplified in the book. It is vivid that during the duration of reading, we see Bederman showing the importance of people, including Ida B. Wells, Theodore Roosevelt, and Jack Johnson. The vital impact is that Berdeman provides us with a connection between these people, although most of them did not know one another. According to Bederman, most nature is labored to make new ideologies of manhood, and this is done by revising and adapting the discourse of civilization. The thesis address by Bederman shows out that, "this book will investigate the turn of the century connection which act between manhood and race. It can argue out that, in 1890-1917, as a while as in the middle- class men who are actively worked to reinforce male power. They also depict their race, which is a factor which is crucial to their gender." She uses a group of people with different cultural assumptions about civilization, race, and manhood to explain facts and points of view.

Is your time best spent reading someone else’s essay? Get a 100% original essay FROM A CERTIFIED WRITER!

Save 25%

The book defines out key concepts which can grasp on how people intentionally and effectively altered the course of history through themselves and especially in American history. She also argues out that gender and power are used in defining attributes of the discourse of civilization. These ideas are important because each person who Bederman discusses uses race, energy, and gender in their perspective and unique always to show their people group on how civilization endorse others. There is a further argument that race and gender need tandem and change throughout American history. Each chapter has a piece of contrary evidence and unique way of how it impends out differences between men as he is used as a means of determining racial dominance. The book covers five different types of chapters, each having its common argument and a primitive form of launching most of civilization. Collectively, Bederman does a great job of showing the importance of these people in their own and respective periods.

Bederman's treatment in this book is worth recounting at large since it illustrates considerable strengths and not on inconsiderable shortcomings. Persuasively, different documents show out ways in which Victorian ideas of manliness with its identification of proper manhood might exist and decipher sexual self-restraint. The epitome of strength has played a vital role in this shift since it can suggest race as being suicidal, which has drastically helped to make most of the actions to happen. Her highly publicized African safari has provided us with a similar impetus, which is used for celebrations of the male aggressiveness. She is also persuasive in showing out the parallel change that exists between the fears of race suicide and the prevalence of neurasthenia. This has been accorded as another danger which is peculiar to the old stock Americans and particularly those who are in the middle and upper class. Bederman links both contemporary nations of change with evolution. For instance, people might believe that being at risk of neurasthenia is the only way they can develop and have enough level of civilization, yet this is subject to demand as addressed by Bederman. Therefore, we need to glorify for strength, which shows out the measure of fitness and ability to reproduce.

An occurrence which has been shown in different chapters of the book shows that black and white male could be on the same playing ground if things were unheard in the first instance. It is seen that Johnson was known for often affiliating with a white woman who has led to some intimidation towards the white men. Many people are still wondering about ways in which Johnson used for success to prove his superior specimen of manhood. Overall, the defeat defiles out a lot of questions about manliness and civilization. Firmly, the ideas put forward by Johnson ensure that the same group of people can address the corresponding consent of the outcome. This idea has still left out an uncertainty that people still question their beliefs.

Bederman carefully describes ways in which Roosevelt and others were able to construct African societies as a prehistoric nature. This was one of the influential people in the era where changes have been shown out. Most of her influences focus on mobs in the south, which should not be discredited. However, Roosevelt shows out that Northern editorials are perfect since they consider lynching to be unmanly. During this time, most African Americans, as seen in the book, have launched a striking fear of the spread of the Negro rapist. Most blacks referred to it as brutal and savage.

Moreover, this has quite been hypocritical since the white Americans are supposed to be the ideal of civilization though they are partaking in activities in different states. It is seen that Wells still is not solely on the same issues as his ending feature on mobbing in the south, which is most of his more extended ideas. Once again, as we go through, we see that Roosevelt and Wells have extraordinary in the making any of people's questions on their very own beliefs, and thus this leads to a future change.

Conclusion

In conclusion, Bederman's thesis shows a connection between manhood and race as a well-supported fact throughout the book. This is seen in different chapters where there is a transition from the effeminate congress of members as each has its ridicule. It is vivid that Bederman has provided a great example of people during the progressive era, such as proof of her thesis focus on Charlotte Perkins Gilman, Theodore Roosevelt, and other fictional characters like Tarzan. One quote that I believed captured one of the many things is based on how tightly the turn of the century American culture interwove issues of gender and race. I also think that Bederman was successful in arguing her case due to the overwhelming amount of facts and examples shown in different chapters. Having all of these real examples provides an authentic look into our history. It still provokes us to diverse thinking about how history shaped us into the modern civilization that we are today. When we tend to look at our past, we force us to many questions that Bederman has dived in the book. This idea creates allegories and epitome of ideal masculinity and manliness since each of the members addressed in the book falls on race, gender, and civilization.

Bibliography

Bederman, Gail. Manliness and civilization: A cultural history of gender and race in the United States, 1880-1917. University of Chicago Press, 2008.