The Rhetorical Force Behind "Nostalgic Grunge" - Essay Sample

Does the introduction give a good indication of what the paper is about?

The introduction is quite clear and gives a good indication about what the topic is about. The writer has been able to give a good narrative and a short history and preview about what is to be expected. It also ends with a thesis statement which is good for the whole read although it is quite a mouthful.

Is your time best spent reading someone else’s essay? Get a 100% original essay FROM A CERTIFIED WRITER!

Save 25%

What is the central argument/thesis of this draft?

As indicated above, the writer has provided a thesis statement which tells us what to expect. It states that the purpose of the paper is to give an in depth study on the effects of black and white photography and performance photography with the aim of showing how these aspects give "Nostalgic Grunge" its unique character.

Explain the central scholarly term(s) the writer is applying to their visual text?

The writer uses certain scholarly terms that are central to the theme of the paper. Nostalgia, meta-sexuality, and parasocial relationships come out clearly all through the text and try to explain how Kurt Cobain's legacy, as well as the relationship with audiences and fans alike, has been kept alive in "Nostalgic Grunge." The writer has also used them appropriately all through the draft although some of them needed defining to give a better understanding especially for readers who are not akin to these terms.

Is this essay organized?

The essay is organized as there is a clear flow from beginning to end. One is able to see the thought process and follow the whole write up from start to finish. However, there are particular areas that the writer could make a few adjustments since there are some difficulties in linking the arguments and paragraphs together especially in the literature review section.

Is the paper free from grammatical/spelling errors?

The paper has very minimal grammatical errors. There are some issues with paraphrasing and using quotations in most part of the paper. Much of the paper is grammatically correct and the writer should be commended for this.

Are citations properly formatted and included on the reference page?

It is evident that the paper follows the APA referencing style. The citations have been well formatted and included on the reference page. Also, since it is APA, there was no need for the introduction heading at the top as it is unnecessary.

What part of the draft is clearest, most effective, most interesting for you as a reader?

The introduction part of the draft is the clearest, most effective and most interesting part all through the paper. The writer was able to give a good introduction and open the door to what is to be expected. Indeed, I wanted to read more just from reading the introduction because the writer gave a good account of what is to be expected, dropped huge names of major artists that were able to capture my attention as a reader.

What part could be strengthened and what specific suggestions can you make for revising it?

The literature review and analysis section are quite confusing. It is quite unclear whether the analysis is part of the literature review or it stands by itself. A huge analysis section seems to be part of the literature review. If the two are separate, then the literature review section is too short and needs more related literature added to the discussion.

Does the conclusion adequately summarize the paper's arguments?

The conclusion is good as it gives a good narration and summarizes the paper's arguments in a good manner. The writer has also given some limitations of the study which is a good aspect. However, he does not offer solutions for future research which is a critical element of the conclusion page.

Answer the question the writer put on the back of their draft?

The parasocial relationship that is created by the viewer of the "Nostalgic Grunge" is clear and strongly presented. The writer indicates that the audience is able to relate with Nirvana and Kurt Cobain without having gone to the concert because of the strong relationship the portrait bears on the audience.